Engineers and manufacturers must ensure precise measurements in parts and assemblies. Tolerances control variations, but choosing the right one is critical. Misunderstanding can lead to production issues, assembly failures, or increased costs.
Unilateral and bilateral tolerances define acceptable deviations in different ways. Using the wrong type can cause mismatched components, wasted materials, or costly rework. Knowing when to use each helps maintain quality and efficiency.
Let’s examine how these two tolerance types differ and when to use each one in engineering projects.
Explanation of tolerance in mechanical design
Tolerance is a key concept in engineering. It defines how much a part’s dimensions can vary and still work correctly. Without tolerances, parts might not fit together or function as intended.
Tolerance defines the acceptable range of variation for dimensions on a technical drawing. For example, if a shaft has a diameter of 10 mm with a tolerance of ±0.05 mm, the actual shaft can measure between 9.95 mm and 10.05 mm and still be considered reasonable.
Every manufactured part has some variation—no machine can make perfectly identical parts. Tolerances give manufacturers clear limits on how much variation is acceptable before a part is rejected.
These tolerances appear on technical drawings as numbers after the primary dimension, like 10±0.05 mm, or as a range, like 9.95-10.05 mm.
What is Unilateral Tolerance?
Unilateral tolerance is a type of dimensional tolerance in which variation is permitted in only one direction (either all positive or all negative) from the basic dimension. This means that the actual size of a part can vary from the nominal size in only one direction—either larger or smaller, but not both.
For example, a shaft might have a diameter of 20.00 mm with a tolerance of +0.05/-0.00 mm. This unilateral tolerance means the shaft diameter can be up to 20.05 mm but not smaller than 20.00 mm. Similarly, a hole might have a diameter of 20.00 mm with a tolerance of +0.00/-0.05 mm, meaning it can be as small as 19.95 mm but not larger than 20.00 mm.
Unilateral tolerances are typically used when a part must not exceed or fall below a particular limit dimension for functional reasons.
How is it applied in engineering drawings？
On engineering drawings, unilateral tolerances are marked to show variation in only one direction. The essential dimension is stated, followed by the allowable deviation. Engineers specify whether the tolerance is positive (above the essential dimension) or negative (below the fundamental dimension).
Common formats include:
- Direct dimension method: 20.00 +0.05/-0.00 mm
- Limit dimension method: 20.00-20.05 mm
- Note method: 20.00 mm +0.05 (or -0.05 for negative unilateral tolerance)
Representation of Unilateral Tolerance
Unilateral tolerances follow standard notation practices according to engineering drawing standards:
- The essential dimension comes first
- The upper deviation follows with a plus (+) sign
- The lower deviation follows with a minus (-) sign
- One of these deviations will be zero in unilateral tolerance
Examples of unilateral tolerance applications
- Shaft diameters for press fit: A shaft with 15.00 +0.02/-0.00 mm ensures the shaft will always be equal to or larger than the essential size, guaranteeing a tight fit.
- Minimum wall thickness for pressure vessels: A vessel wall might be specified as 8.00 +0.50/-0.00 mm, ensuring the wall is never thinner than the minimum safe thickness.
- Circuit board hole positions: Hole locations might have tolerances of ±0.00/+0.10 mm, ensuring components never interfere.
- Maximum height dimensions: A maximum height might be specified as 50.00 +0.00/-0.30 mm for parts that must fit within a fixed space.
Advantages of Unilateral Tolerance
Easier manufacturing control
Unilateral tolerance simplifies manufacturing by focusing on one direction of variation. This makes it easier to adjust tools and processes to meet the specifications.
Simplified inspection and quality assurance
Inspecting parts with unilateral tolerance is straightforward. Inspectors only need to check if the dimension falls within the allowed range in one direction, reducing the time and effort needed for quality control.
What is Bilateral Tolerance？
Bilateral tolerance is a type of dimensional tolerance where variation is permitted in both directions (positive and negative) from the essential dimension. With bilateral tolerance, the actual size of a part can be either larger or smaller than the nominal size within specified limits.
For example, a shaft might have a diameter of 20.00 mm with a bilateral tolerance of ±0.03 mm. This means the shaft diameter can range from 19.97 mm to 20.03 mm and still be considered acceptable. The variation is distributed on both sides of the basic dimension.
Bilateral tolerances are commonly used for general dimensions where slight variations in either direction won’t affect the function of the part.
How is it applied in engineering drawings？
On engineering drawings, bilateral tolerances are marked to show equal or unequal variation in both directions from the essential dimension. The fundamental dimension is stated first, followed by the allowable deviations.
Common formats include:
- Equal bilateral: 20.00 ±0.03 mm (variation is the same in both directions)
- Unequal bilateral: 20.00 +0.05/-0.02 mm (different amounts of variation in each direction)
- Limit dimension method: 19.97-20.03 mm (showing the minimum and maximum limits directly)
Representation of Bilateral Tolerance
Bilateral tolerances follow standard notation according to engineering drawing standards:
- The essential dimension comes first
- For equal bilateral tolerances, a plus/minus (±) symbol is used, followed by the deviation value
- For unequal bilateral tolerances, the upper deviation with a plus (+) sign and lower deviation with a minus (-) sign are both provided
- Both deviations have non-zero values in bilateral tolerance
Examples of bilateral tolerance applications
- General dimensions of machined components: A plate width might be specified as 100.00 ±0.50 mm for general-purpose applications.
- Hole diameters for sliding fits: To achieve the proper fit balance, a bearing hole might be specified as 25.00 +0.02/-0.01 mm.
- PCB trace width: Circuit board traces might have width tolerances of 0.50 ±0.05 mm to maintain electrical performance while accommodating manufacturing variability.
- 판금 굽힘 dimensions: A bend angle might be specified as 90° ±1° to account for 스프링 백 and tooling variations.
- Plastic part molding: Injection-molded parts often use bilateral tolerances, like 30.00 ±0.20 mm, for material shrinkage and mold wear.
Advantages of Bilateral Tolerance
Balanced material distribution
Bilateral tolerance allows material to be added or removed equally. This helps maintain balance in the part’s design and reduces stress concentrations.
Greater flexibility in manufacturing
Manufacturers have more flexibility with bilateral tolerance. They can adjust tools and processes to stay within the tolerance range without worrying about a single direction of variation. This often leads to faster production and lower costs.
Key Differences Between Unilateral and Bilateral Tolerance
Understanding unilateral and bilateral tolerance differences helps engineers choose the right design approach. Here’s a breakdown of the key distinctions:
정의
- Unilateral Tolerance: Allows variation in only one direction from the nominal size (larger or smaller).
- Bilateral Tolerance: Allows variation from the nominal size (larger and smaller).
Variation Direction
- Unilateral Tolerance: Variation is restricted to one side of the nominal dimension. For example, 10 mm +0.2/-0 means the part can be up to 0.2 mm larger but not smaller.
- Bilateral Tolerance: Variation is allowed on both sides of the nominal dimension. For example, 10 mm ±0.1 mm means the part can be 0.1 mm larger or smaller.
Design Intent
- Unilateral Tolerance: Used when precise fit in one direction is critical. For example, a shaft must not exceed a specific size to fit into a hole.
- Bilateral Tolerance: Used when slight variations on either side of the nominal size are acceptable. For example, a bracket’s dimensions can vary slightly without affecting its function.
Manufacturing Flexibility
- Unilateral Tolerance: Limits manufacturing flexibility because variation is allowed in only one direction. This can increase costs if the tolerance is tight.
- Bilateral Tolerance: Offers greater flexibility because variation is permitted in both directions. This often makes it easier and more cost-effective to produce parts.
| 측면 | Unilateral Tolerance | Bilateral Tolerance |
|---|---|---|
| 정의 | Variation allowed in only one direction (larger or smaller). | Variation allowed in both directions (larger and smaller). |
| Variation Direction | One-sided (e.g., +0.2/-0 or +0/-0.2). | Two-sided (e.g., ±0.1). |
| Design Intent | Used when precise fit in one direction is critical. | Used when slight variations on either side are acceptable. |
| Manufacturing Flexibility | Less flexible; tighter control in one direction. | More flexible; easier to achieve in production. |
Other Types of Engineering Tolerances
Besides unilateral and bilateral tolerances, engineers use several other important tolerance types to control various aspects of part quality and function. Each serves specific design needs and manufacturing scenarios.
기하 치수 및 공차(GD&T)
GD&T is a comprehensive system that goes beyond simple dimensional tolerances. It controls geometric characteristics like form, orientation, location, and runout. This system uses symbols and rules to define the exact shape and position requirements of features on a part.
Key GD&T tolerance types include:
- Form tolerances: Control straightness, flatness, circularity, and cylindricity
- Orientation tolerances: Control parallelism, perpendicularity, and angularity
- Location tolerances: Control position, concentricity, and symmetry
- Runout tolerances: Control circular and total runout
GD&T provides more precise control over part geometry than traditional dimensional tolerancing alone.
Statistical Tolerances
Statistical tolerancing uses probability and statistics to predict how variations in individual dimensions will affect an assembly. Unlike worst-case tolerancing, which assumes all parts are at their extreme limits, statistical tolerancing recognizes that most parts will be closer to the nominal dimension.
This approach uses symbols like “ST” or “RSS” (Root Sum Square) on drawings to indicate where statistical methods apply. It often allows for wider individual tolerances while still maintaining overall assembly quality.
Limit Tolerances
Limit tolerancing directly specifies the maximum and minimum allowable dimensions without referencing an essential dimension. For example, a shaft diameter might be 15.02-15.05 mm.
This method communicates the acceptable range and is often used in production environments where direct measurement comparisons are made.
Fit Tolerances
Fit tolerances control how parts interact when assembled. They define the clearance or interference between mating parts. Standard fit systems include:
- Clearance fits: The hole is always more significant than the shaft, allowing free movement
- Interference fits: The shaft is always more significant than the hole, creating a press fit
- Transition fits: Sometimes clearance, sometimes interference, depending on the actual sizes
Fit tolerances are typically defined according to standardized systems like ISO or ANSI, with designations such as H7/f7 (clearance fit) or H7/s6 (interference fit).
Non-Uniform Tolerances
Non-uniform tolerances vary along the length or area of a feature. For example, a tapered shaft might have tighter tolerances at the bearing surface and looser tolerances elsewhere. This approach optimizes manufacturing costs by applying tight tolerances only where functionally necessary.
Profile Tolerances
Profile tolerances control the overall shape of a surface by specifying how much it can deviate from the theoretical perfect shape. They’re often used for complex curved surfaces or aesthetic features.
Profile tolerances can be applied to:
- Line profiles (2D)
- Surface profiles (3D)
They’re commonly used in automotive body panels, consumer products, and aerospace components.
Material Condition Modifiers
These modifiers adjust tolerance zones based on the actual size of a feature:
- Maximum Material Condition (MMC): Applies when the feature contains the most material
- 최소 재료 조건(LMC): Applies when the feature includes the least material
- Regardless of Feature Size (RFS): Applies irrespective of the feature’s actual size
These modifiers help ensure parts fit together correctly while maximizing manufacturing flexibility.
결론
Engineering tolerances play a crucial role in designing and manufacturing quality parts. Unilateral and bilateral tolerances represent two fundamental approaches to controlling dimensional variation.
The choice between these tolerance types depends on specific design requirements, manufacturing capabilities, and cost considerations. Engineers must consider the function of each feature, available manufacturing processes, and inspection methods when selecting the appropriate tolerance type.
At Shengen, we deliver high-quality sheet metal fabrication and precision manufacturing services. Whether you need help with tolerances, prototyping, or mass production, our experienced team is here to support you. 문의하기 지금 바로 프로젝트에 대해 논의하고 무료 견적을 받아보세요!
안녕하세요, 저는 케빈 리입니다
지난 10년 동안 저는 다양한 형태의 판금 제작에 몰두해 왔으며 다양한 워크숍에서 얻은 경험에서 얻은 멋진 통찰력을 이곳에서 공유했습니다.
연락하세요
케빈 리
저는 레이저 절단, 굽힘, 용접 및 표면 처리 기술을 전문으로 하는 판금 제조 분야에서 10년 이상의 전문 경험을 갖고 있습니다. Shengen의 기술 이사로서 저는 복잡한 제조 문제를 해결하고 각 프로젝트에서 혁신과 품질을 주도하는 데 최선을 다하고 있습니다.
